Philip Rosedale, CEO of High Fidelity and founder of Second Life, announced at a High Fidelity community meeting recently that the company will be scaling back their VR efforts, focusing more on improving their PC and Mac performance. The company has also shut down all first-party user spaces and associated servers except for a single orientation room, which will be used for new users only.

High Fidelity is still allowing individual users to run their own spaces/servers, although refocusing efforts to flush out its desktop client and encourage user-generated spaces undoubtedly comes as a cost-savings maneuver by the company.

As first reported by New World Notes, Rosedale’s reasoning behind the move comes down to a pretty big linchpin: VR headsets sales. They simply aren’t getting into enough hands to make the company profitable in its current form.

“One thing to do, which all the companies have been doing, is better support for desktop users. Because any assessment of the rate of progress on HMDs is a sobering one; they’re not selling enough to create a general-purpose community that is both interesting and profitable,” Rosedale said at the meeting. “So, it’s really important to recognize, that through no fault of our collective selves, it’s not working. This model is not working right now. The flat world, that is an open building environment, is not compelling enough as it stands right now for the number of HMDs that are out there to get lift off. And so we’ve gotta think hard about that.”

“We’re not a social VR game.”

We’ve typically described High Fidelity as a social VR platform, although according to Rosedale, that’s not entirely an accurate description.

“We’re not a social VR game. We’re actually not. This is not a chat application where we get together and hang in a room talking to each other. High Fidelity was designed to be a platform anticipating the very broad use of VR across the Internet for things like this—public meetings, going to work, going to school— doing all kinds of different things.”

the now-defunct virtual item showcase ‘Avatar Island’, Image courtesy High Fidelity

Rosedale says that while they’ve done their best to get that aspect of their business started, the company feels it’s making a mistake by taking an active role in the community by supporting first-party spaces. This, he says, comes down to the company’s inability to manage ban lists and moderate users.

“What we feel like is we’re actively doing a disservice to everyone by running these public spaces. Instead, what we ought to have is you guys running your own spaces, that each have a different character. I would imagine that there are five or six distinct groups of people already in this room who to a large extent already have pretty different rules to their standard and everything else.”

Reading between the lines somewhat: it’s apparent that hosting servers for a low concurrent user base hasn’t helped the company to see a return on their $73 million investment, the latest $35 million injection arriving in June 2018. Rosedale however has confidence in individual users to fill the void that its first-party servers will leave behind.

The Surprising Brilliance of 'Vacation Simulator's' VR Paintbrush Tech

High Fidelity, Low Concurrents

To Rosedale, there’s at least one big barrier to getting the sort of concurrent user numbers it needs to to drive its in-world economy. Speaking to New World Notes, he says that social VR simply won’t work “until we can do everything in them, including work and messaging. We can’t multi-task in VR yet, and that’s a real challenge.”

While its still very much early days for VR in general, Rosedale contends that many social VR companies are facing the same issue with low concurrent users.

“Let’s actually add all [users from NeosVR, Anyland, and Rec Room] together into one product. That company will not survive. There’s not enough revenue,” he said at the community meeting. “Everybody here that’s having such a good time: you guys need to pay us $10,000 a month for us to keep the company going indefinitely into the future, for us to basically be a positive cash-flow company, as we say here in The Valley. And everybody else in VR right now is faced by that.”

Image courtesy High Fidelity

Rosedale additionally said that bug fixing and other VR-specific improvements to the platform won’t be enough to get the company cash flow-even as long as VR headset adoption is low.

“There should be 15, 20, 50 people around the table right now making a living in here. And we’re not there yet. So we gotta figure that out,” he said.

High Fidelity notably created their own cryptocurrency and blockchain-based ledger system, the latter of which allows authentication of in-game items—seemingly the right ingredients to attract the sort of virtual business moguls and regular users that once populated Second Life. But High Fidelity isn’t Second Life, Rosedale says.

You guys, this is not Second Life in 2004. Second Life actually took off like a rocket once it got working. Even though it had tons and tons of problems—but it took off like an absolute rocket. And the reason that it did, I think, was that this experience of bringing a lot of people together and letting them build things together live, well, in the time frame when we built Second Life, it had never, ever been seen by anyone. It was the most exceptional, jaw-dropping thing that anybody had ever seen except in science fiction.

Rosedale attributes Second Life’s meteoric success due to the relative lack of similar platforms and services back in the early 2000s, something that’s changed quite a bit in the meantime.

Social VR Hits 'Rec Room' and 'VRChat' Coming to Oculus Quest

“That doesn’t mean that we’re not going to make it. It simply means that we have to be more clever, and the strategy that we use to get people in here has to be somewhat different,” Rosedale says.

As for the industry’s most successful VR multi-user space, VRChat still boasts concurrent users in the thousands, according to Steam Charts. At the time of this writing, there are estimated to be around 3,000 players spread across multiple worlds within the platform. There’s no way of telling how many of those are using VR headsets, although its likely a majority are on desktop.

That said, VRChat can largely be considered a freak of nature, thanks in part to its wide-reaching success on social media and YouTube. Whatever the case, one important lesson to learn for the platform’s success is that low numbers are typically a self-fulling prophecy: if few users are online, people simply won’t stick around for long enough to generate the vibrant digital communities that so many are looking to inhabit. In this case, the contrapositive is true for VRChat, which only demonstrates the need for raw user numbers in a time when VR headsets are still a rarity.

When asked by New World Notes what he thought about the coming tide of new VR devices, specifically the standalone 6DOF headsets Quest and Vive Focus, Rosedale thinks they’re “the future,” although he posits VR is still going to take a few years to reach mass adoption. High Fidelity previously announced plans to support Quest back in February, although considering today’s news, Quest support may inevitably be placed on the backburner.

– – — – –

You can watch the full video of the community meeting below; Rosedale begins with his news announcement, and then opens the floor to community questions.

A special thanks goes out to Ryan Schultz for his work on creating a transcript of the meeting.

Newsletter graphic

This article may contain affiliate links. If you click an affiliate link and buy a product we may receive a small commission which helps support the publication. More information.

Well before the first modern XR products hit the market, Scott recognized the potential of the technology and set out to understand and document its growth. He has been professionally reporting on the space for nearly a decade as Editor at Road to VR, authoring more than 4,000 articles on the topic. Scott brings that seasoned insight to his reporting from major industry events across the globe.
  • 3872Orcs

    They need to get the equivalent of a Knuckles meme going :p

    • Firestorm185

      Agreed, a good meme goes a long way.

  • OkinKun

    Hope they don’t make the same mistake again.. This was my problem with Second Life originally, they created a virtual world, but without virtual reality.. It just wasn’t that interesting to most people, on a flat 2d screen. Of course that’s not so much their fault, as the fact that VR tech just didn’t exist for consumers back then..
    But if they turn their focus away from VR now, they’re crazy.. And it would be their fault.
    I have zero interest in socializing in virtual worlds, without virtual reality. And little interest in exploring and socializing in such worlds, without the level of VR hand interaction that the VR industry is moving towards. And if VR isn’t one of their main focuses, then they aren’t going to have the level of VR features and interactivity that other VR games have, and they’ll fall behind.

    • Yikes! Seriously, what is it with people missing the memo? They get the desktop camera stuff working and suddenly it is headlines that Hifi is abandoning VR. Christ…

      Yes, the desktop system is getting a makeover, mostly because the desktop experience wasn’t very good, and this somewhat flowed into the VR experience. No, VR is not being left out. The problem, as Philip mentioned, is VR adoption wasn’t as high as he had hoped for and most of High Fidelity’s resources was towards creating VR experiences. The problem is that other users also tried to create these as well, but things like the money tree (a tree that gave out money over time) pulled users from seeing these, leaving little incentive to actually visit them.

      On top of that, most people coming into High Fidelity were coming in on desktop mode first, and typically VR later. The issue is the desktop experience had little to no polish, and that didn’t entice a good majority of people. Plus, the limitations on desktop mode made it difficult for people to make experience all could enjoy.

      In the end, they shutdown their public spaces to entice users to create their own experiences (or better highlight them) and focus less on content creation (on their own stuff) and more on infrastructure to house the content made by users. No, VR mode isn’t going away and at no point did he say it was going away.

      • Adeline

        Do you want reliable online earning money opportunity to generate atleast $7400 once per month? Then you are at the best place for the reason that I am getting that much since 6 months now. There is no one saying to you what to do,get your laptop with internet connection, carry it to seaside beach or even a park or mountain, and complete your projects peacefully with nature. In Online earning, simply take your laptop along with you on your family holiday. Here’s the only way to start

  • Justos

    VRChat killed high fidelity, imo, they are trying to do something that VRChat already does well, a bit late.

  • Winston Lowe

    if you liked HF you should give Neos VR a try, even Rosedale was blown way by the level access you to make things.

  • Enbee

    I feel like everyone wants to be the first to build “The OASIS” and are expecting to make the money it did but they are trying to take shortcuts and not actually include meaningful content. When the OASIS launched it included gameplay and wasn’t just an empty platform where they expected others to fill it and make it interesting.

  • Foreign Devil

    Too bad. I think Philip is just ahead of his time with this. I really liked the direction he was taking High Fidelity. . but if there’s no money there’s no way. Luck and timing figure hugely in a successful venture like Second Life was.

  • sebrk

    VRChat probably won the race so far. Plus since Oculus introduced shared homes that put even more preassure on it. Been a bit of a boom of similar stuff and now the winner takes it all.

  • sfmike

    Just my opinion but I think the exclusion of adult content is another reason more people aren’t attracted to High Fidelity as this certainly has helped keep Second Life alive. I actually visited High Fidelity often but didn’t create due to the high learning curve on creation and lack of users. Enjoyed their large scale events but that was the only thing happening. I think their new direction is a huge mistake.

  • HybridEnergy

    I never heard of them or their game, meeting room simulator, social thing but not social thing before in my life. Not sure they’re marketing it properly, but yea…while VR seems like a cool place to hang out and talk to your boss (not) most of us just kind of want to shoot stuff and throw tron balls at each other. Sorry.

  • Chinamini aspie angel

    Oh god they are so slow to realize things!
    Since its release I saw it was suicide to insist!
    It should be a feature, it should be just a obrigatory feature!