‘FlyInside Flight Simulator’ Preview – A Promising Start in VR-native Flying

14

FlyInside FSX, the crowdfunded VR plugin for Microsoft Flight Simulator X (2006), was built well before first-party VR motion controllers existed, developed back in the DK2-era of 2015 as an ad hoc way of jumping into an already highly-detailed flight sim. Now, the creators of FlyInside FSX have released their own dedicated flight simulator in beta, dubbed FlyInside Flight Simulator, that’s built from the ground-up for VR.

FlyInside Flight Simulator isn’t hitting Steam or the Oculus Store yet though, as the company is launching beta access for both their free trial version and a paid ‘pro version’ first through their website starting today to get the valuable feedback and start building a community around the fledgling flight sim.

I’ve had some experience with flight sims in my time, and although I wouldn’t consider myself an enthusiast, with a little gumption (and handy instructions) I can usually figure out my way around a plane. FlyInside has a few short tutorials with voice overs and handy indicators to tell you locations of major controls and instruments so you’re not sitting parked on the runway without a clue, although don’t expect a full flight school just yet, as they only cover the basics. You can also set the flight difficulty to easy, medium and realistic, which determines how much power you have, and how responsive the controls are.

 

That said, like all flight sims, FlyInside has a definite learning curve, as it seeks to accurately simulate everything from Cessna prop planes all the way up to Chinook helicopters, each with their own control intricacies that hardcore flight sim proponents love to dig into. What’s different about FlyInside though is both Rift and Vive users can use their respective motion controllers to manipulate levers, buttons, and requisite knobs. Leap Motion is also supported too, letting you manipulate controls in the cockpit with your own two hands.

At the time of this writing, FlyInside boasts over 15 major plane and helicopter types (with more subtypes) that include all of the realistic instruments you’d expect.

Image courtesy FlyInside

FlyInside also comes replete with configurable time, weather, and the trial version ships with around 40,000 square miles of Utah and Nevada. The full version will come with the full continental Unites States, meaning you can fly from Florida to Oregon in VR.

It’s still early days for FlyInside. While I had no trouble hitting 90 fps, one of the biggest pain points currently in FlyInside’s early open beta are how you manipulate levers, buttons and menus with motion controllers. While there is haptic feedback, I found my natural inclination to grab levers to be a bit of a let down. The current VR controller implementation makes manually adjusting controls sort of a guessing game that can be frustrating at times, requiring a delicate touch with a single extended finger to manipulate most buttons; I never really got hang of actually using motion controllers to manipulate important controls like the yoke or the thrusters, but they are entirely serviceable provided you make sure your controllers aren’t occluded by your desk.

 

If you have a HOTAS setup (and I imagine you do if you’re a flight sim enthusiast), it’s advised to break out the keybinding menu and forgo motion controllers for a majority of flight controls at this early stage considering how floaty they feel, despite some haptic feedback to let you know when you’re touching a button. There’s also keyboard and mouse support, the latter of which I found useful for re-positioning menus, which you can put around the cockpit at any position you find comfortable.

In the end though, FlyInside brings nearly everything to the table that VR flight sim enthusiasts are sure to enjoy, including a multiplayer function so you can fly around with your friends. With a little more love in the VR controls department, it’s truly poised to give other VR-compatible flight sims like X-Plane 11 a run for their money.

SEE ALSO
This Awesome DIY VR Cockpit Hides a Flight Simulator in Plain Sight

The studio hasn’t set a definite launch window for Steam and Oculus Store yet, although they’re currently pricing the ‘pro version’ to appeal to its original Kickstarter backers at $20, and existing customers at $25. Brand new customers can expect to pay $32 for the full game.

Future development items include:

  • Expanded Scenery – We have a Europe scenery under development, and will target global scenery after
  • Improved Scenery – Most of our development so far has been on the simulator engine itself. It can push huge amounts of auto-gen, but is mostly drawing “developer art.” Now that the first version is out the door, we’ll be working with artists to enhance the scenery content itself.
  • Offline ATC – We want to build a living world. This includes intelligent air traffic, and an ATC system you can interact with.
  • Additional Aircraft – We’re working with multiple aircraft developers to port additional aircraft to FlyInside Flight Simulator. Some will be added to the base simulator, as free updates.
  • Realistic G1000, G530 style avionics – Right now our digital avionics are fairly basic displays. The goal is to fill them in and create units worth practicing navigation with.
  • Much much more – There are few projects more ambituous than a flight simulator. We plan to add features and fixes for years to come.

This article may contain affiliate links. If you click an affiliate link and buy a product we may receive a small commission which helps support the publication. See here for more information.


Well before the first modern XR products hit the market, Scott recognized the potential of the technology and set out to understand and document its growth. He has been professionally reporting on the space for nearly a decade as Editor at Road to VR, authoring more than 3,500 articles on the topic. Scott brings that seasoned insight to his reporting from major industry events across the globe.
  • Jan Ciger

    I am afraid that there isn’t much one can do about those “floaty buttons”. That’s a problem as old as VR itself. Unless we have gloves with very high resolution feedback actuators (the current “bzzzt-bzzt” buzzing “feedback” or the types that tug or press on your fingers really don’t count) the only way to get good haptic feedback of switches and controls in VR is to use actual switches and controls there. They don’t need to be physically doing anything but they give the hands and the brain something to “feel”.

    This is also why you won’t find a professional flight simulator using an HMD – they always go for an actual cockpit and projections even though it is more expensive. The muscle memory and the tactile feedback matter a lot.

    • jj

      This is a solution to avoiding the costs and housing on an actual cockpit…. it goes without saying that the real thing is better.
      The cost and usability of this solution matter more than muscle memory and tactile feedback.

      • Engineer_92

        I agree. Comparing an HMD to a dedicated simulator is kinda like comparing oranges to grapefruit. They’re alike, but looking deeper, they cater to different preferences in experience. Its not really fair to compare the two

        • jj

          yeah, and you’re an engineer.

        • Jan Ciger

          You are forgetting an important point – whether it is driving or flying, being able to operate these controls without looking, by touch is extremely important – both for safety and to be able to do it quickly.

          Otherwise you have an arcade game and not a simulator. Which is fine if that’s what you are after but then why the lack of haptic feedback would be a problem in the article?

      • Yosarin Blake

        Not mention the fact that you can switch between different “cockpits” at the press of a button. Can’t do that with a physical sim obviously!

    • Manifesting presence with inherently ‘non-objects’ is difficult, although there are a few ancillary tricks developers use to make objects ‘feel’ more solid. Making hands unable to clip through geometry, allowing for hand-attachable hardpoints, more definitive audio cues, and more detailed use of the haptic actuators – like experience you can find in Valve’s ‘The Lab’ mini-game ‘Long Bow’ all provide a number of ways to make you more invested in the action of hitting a switch, or picking up something that’s supposed to be heavy.

      I’m not certain any VR developer creating their own fictional experience from scratch would opt for the sheer density of controls that flight sims offer though. That said, there’s a margin for improvement that would make such a flight sim conceivably more immersive and playable for those opting for pure motion controller interaction.

      In the end, I don’t see VR flight sims competing on the same playing field as dedicated flight simulators. They’re meant for the home enthusiast and the casual player who want a more visually immersive experience while conceivably already using a HOTAS with most important functions mapped away to physical buttons.

      • Jan Ciger

        There is actually an entire field of research on “pseudo-haptic” feedback. Mostly work of Lécuyer, et al:

        https://people.rennes.inria.fr/Anatole.Lecuyer/presence_lecuyer_draft.pdf

        He uses multimodal cues (sound, visual cues) to give the impression of different surface textures or features. Haven’t seen any of this stuff in a VR game yet, though.

        The problem with the switches in the plane cockpit isn’t so much the “report” you get when you touch it or toggle something but the fact that you absolutely must look at your hand to see what you are doing. Which is distracting. A normal pilot would be able to operate e.g. gear or flaps simply by reaching and finding those levers by touch (they usually have a very distinctive shape).

    • w

      i just wanna know if the game is fun

  • ummm…

    ive used fly inside with p3d and fsx since vive launch. great fun. totally suprised to hear of this. is it fsx at core?

  • JesuSaveSouls

    This dev is a genius who gave us vr with fsx and xplane11 way before anything was native.

  • gothicvillas

    Hope their environments are more pleasing than the rest vr fly sims out there (vegetation, traffic, buildings, airports etc etc). Flying over flat boring world gets old very quick.

  • sebrk

    Wonder if this works with motion simulators loke Yaw VR?

  • 4fr29

    Are there any plans to add motion code for a motion seat so you could feel things like thrust, banking, turbulence, landing, reverse thrust etc… ?