Toast Interactive announced their VR games Max Mustard (2024) and Richie’s Plank Experience (2017) have been removed from the Horizon Store for Quest. For now, it’s unclear precisely why, however the veteran indie studio says the move has left them feeling “betrayed and powerless.”

“Unfortunately, Meta has unilaterally chosen to remove Toast and its two games, Max Mustard and Richies Plank Experience from their store,” the studio says in a post on X. “We feel betrayed and powerless on many levels.”

While temporary delisting can happen by mistake, this doesn’t appear to be the case. There is a reason, however Toast Interactive says it can’t talk about it yet, separately noting the studio “look[s] forward to sharing our story with you all in the near future.”

In a Reddit post, Toast Interactive says the reason will “blow everyone’s minds. But I’ve been firmly advised not to.”

On both the Max Mustard and Richie’s Plank Experience Horizon Store pages, the reason listed is the apps are “out of compliance with Meta’s Platform Abuse Policy,” although there’s no information on specifically how it fell out of compliance.

Image captured by Road to VR

The company’s platform abuse policy covers a wide range of offenses, such as pirated content, security exploits, or deception of any kind, however it also covers more nebulous areas that are likely left up to interpretation.

Not following developer documentation, or “any other provisions of the Meta Platforms Technologies Terms of Service or Code of Conduct for Virtual Experiences, or any other Meta Platforms Technologies terms, policies or guidelines” can also get an app removed with or without warning, Meta says in its Platform Abuse Policy.

SEE ALSO
Prop Hunt-style Game 'Mannequin' Goes Free-to-Play on Quest as Freemium Multiplayer Games Thrive

Notably, both games are still available across their other supported platforms, with Max Mustard supporting PC VR, PSVR 2 and Pico headsets, and Richie’s Plank Experience supporting PC VR, the original PSVR and Pico headsets.

This comes at one of the most inopportune times for Toast Interactive. Last month the Gold Coast, Australia-based studio announced it was closing office and laying off a majority of staff.

This follows a first layoff round in November 2024, which affected 10 employees. At the time, the studio maintained that while Max Mustard was “one of the highest-rated games on both PSVR 2 and Meta Quest, it sadly can’t sustain a large indie team.”


This story is breaking: we’ve reached out to Meta for more clarity on the situation and will report back when/if we receive a response, or as more information arises.

Newsletter graphic

This article may contain affiliate links. If you click an affiliate link and buy a product we may receive a small commission which helps support the publication. More information.

Well before the first modern XR products hit the market, Scott recognized the potential of the technology and set out to understand and document its growth. He has been professionally reporting on the space for nearly a decade as Editor at Road to VR, authoring more than 4,000 articles on the topic. Scott brings that seasoned insight to his reporting from major industry events across the globe.
  • Ondrej

    Every time people praise the concept of walled garden platforms I lose faith in humanity.

    Computers were never supposed to be like this. A device you paid for should be yours. A contract between a developer and a consumer should not be voided by some tollbooth tax collector with control fetish.

    Kicking whoever you want for whatever reason is perfectly fine – it's your digital store. But this is NOT the case here. They are kicking them from a computer – from a piece of hardware.
    And no, those esoteric side loading methods do not count as practical distribution channels. So using that excuse is a one big apathetic lie.

    BTW, Valve Deckard will have the same problem if it works anything like Steam Deck – another walled garden shamelessly BS-ing that it's not one, just because it allows to tinker in economically irrelevant way (!), outside of the UI locked steam monopoly. If these games were kicked out of Steam they would be just as doomed on Deckard as they are on Quest -> no sales.

    In other words, this whole "future of computing" is completely doomed by Web 2.0 era greed. Apple turning AVP into iPad on face with Mac OS apps banned forever was the final nail in the coffin.

    • Herbert Werters

      You can also install and run all sorts of things on the Steam Deck under the Steam OS. That is complete nonsense. The only thing that doesn't work is the XBOX Gamepass and stupid anticheat software but that's not because of Valve that they don't work but because there is no way to install the gamepass via installer and anticheat works on kernel level.

    • Peter vasseur

      Most journalists aren’t. They all just too scared to say anything, because pick your excuse.

    • VR Smurf

      There's always hope that Android XR will be forkable like the Android OS but its unlikely given that Samsung will probably be starting out caving in to their corporate overlords!

  • MrGreen72

    That must be in line with Zuck's new free speech agenda right?

    Oh wait…

    • Peter vasseur

      Meta can suck it, I wouldn’t buy a dam thing from them.

  • ApocalypseShadow

    It's all fun and games until they start taking them away. What did they actually do to have their game taken down? While on PC and console, no problems there.

    Then, in a turn around twist, they'll probably buy the developers who made the game so that they can make an internal, Astrobot like game made by "Facebook." Since Astrobot is riding on a high on consoles. Got to make a competing product or make it exclusive.

    Just like Facebook bought the developer that made Iron Man VR and had them make a Batman game. Two franchise games that were very popular on console VR. The Batman game became exclusive on Quest and no updated port for PS VR 2 with Iron Man.

    • Kuzuma

      I don't understand why are you salty about them buying Camouflage studio, they saw potential in them so they added the studio to their Oculus Studio. As for the Astrobot like game, I think your reasoning is groundless. The dev have yet to clarify the reason for their ban, maybe they are trying through bad PR to pressure Meta to undo the ban. Plus the comment above left by deloris showed their shady past behavior. Not defending Meta or anything but let's be fair, in no way banning a developer and having PR nightmare does help Meta. (Yes I know Meta fumble alot, but let's wait until dev or meta clarify the reason behind the ban and not jump to groundless conclusions)

  • Nicolas

    I bought Max Mustard for Quest. Does this mean I can't access it anymore, even without ever having played it?
    I wonder if it's it legal for them to take a product from me that I paid for. For anyone with a sound mind, I'd have to be reimbursed for it.
    Customer rights, anyone?

    • Herbert Werters

      The game is still there. Nobody is taking anything away from you. It's just been removed from the store. It's still in your library.

  • Delores Bateman

    Here's some context from several years ago, when the Ritchie's Plank Experience developers were banned from the /r/Vive subreddit –

    We Broke the Rules

    Around this time last year, we released the Santa Simulator update. I was so excited, I asked our Steam fans to upvote the post on Reddit. This broke the rules and it was removed by the moderators. Desperate, I broke the rules again to post Santa on /r/Vive. Then I doubled down and tried to mislead the moderators about this. I tried to reconcile with the moderators througout the year. I didn't receive a response.

    Yesterday, we Broke the Rules Again

    For the first time in a year, we broke the rules again by posting about the grand opening update. We were excited for /r/Vive to see our surprises. We used a 3rd account. The post is deleted and we're now banned again for ban evasion, probably beyond reconciliation. Please don't blame the mods. They were just following the rules.

    Unfortunately, we have now come to the realisation that we can't be a part of the /r/Vive community anymore. If you don't see us being involved, it's not because we don't care.

    Look, we all know Reddit mods are lame humans by definition. And I say that as literally an ex-mod of r/Vive. Not the best and brightest. But still….

    I know you can't surmise a pattern from 1 incident (I prefer 3), but if they're being vague on why they were kicked from the Meta store for breaking rules, who wants to bet it was another case of them manipulating placement/reviews/rating on Meta's store?

    Just a random guess, nothing concrete obviously.

    • Jeff

      Thanks for the insight- that does shed some light on past behavior. We should all wait until they are able to provide more details to make any judgment towards either party though.

    • psuedonymous

      On top of that:

      Toast Interactive says the reason will “blow everyone’s minds. But I’ve been firmly advised not to.”

      roughly translates to "we know how we violated the Platform Abuse Policy, but our lawyers have told us not to say it". which is rarely the outcome for something innocuous.

  • I'm interested to know the reasons before making any judgement.

  • ZarathustraDK

    I heard some rumors that the spat stemmed from some kind of ingame cross-promotin they did for Max Mustard inside Ritchie's Plank Experiment, something about a 90% discount IIRC.

    If so, that's pretty draconian of Meta.